Design Operations Optimization
Designer Mentorship Guidance
Design System Creation
TABLE OF
CONTENTS
Introduction
Summary
Goal
Problem / Solution
Product Definition
Define project and scope
Value proposition mapping
Concept sketching
Research
Stakeholder interviews
Individual in-depth interviews (IDI)
Competitive research
Analysis
Creating user personas
Creating user stories
Storyboarding
Low Fidelity
Sketching
Creating wireframes
Design Presentation
High Fidelity
High Fidelity Mockup
Creating prototypes
Creating a design specification
Adoption
Analytics
Excellence
Conclusion
SUMMARY
Crafting User-Centric Masterpieces
Orchestrating Cohesion
The design process is a meticulously orchestrated journey that transforms initial concepts into fully realized, user-centric products. It begins with an intricate alignment of stakeholder objectives, ensuring that the vision for the product is cohesive and clearly defined. By immersing in user research and leveraging insights from various disciplines, the design process captures the nuanced needs and desires of the target audience. This foundational understanding drives the ideation phase, where creativity and strategic thinking converge to generate innovative solutions that resonate deeply with users.
​
Delving Into Nuance
As the process advances, these ideas are refined through iterative sketching, wireframing, and prototyping, each stage adding layers of detail and fidelity. High-fidelity designs are meticulously crafted, embodying both aesthetic elegance and functional precision. The collaboration between design and development teams is paramount, as the transition from concept to implementation requires seamless communication and a shared commitment to excellence. The result is a harmonious blend of form and function, delivering a product that not only meets but exceeds user expectations and business objectives.
GOAL
Understanding the Design Process
Fostering Alignment and Collaboration
The goal of discussing the design process is to illuminate the structured methodology behind creating successful, user-centered products. By comprehensively understanding this process, stakeholders can better appreciate the rationale and strategic thinking that guide each design decision. This knowledge fosters greater alignment and collaboration among business, product, engineering, and data science teams, ensuring that everyone is working towards a unified vision.
​
Highlighting User-Centered Design and Strategic Excellence
Furthermore, a clear exposition of the design process highlights the importance of user research, iterative refinement, and cross-disciplinary cooperation. It underscores how thoughtful design can address user needs, solve real-world problems, and ultimately drive business success. By demystifying the process, we can cultivate a shared commitment to excellence, ensuring that the final product not only meets but surpasses expectations, creating value for both users and the organization.
PROBLEM
Misalignment and Inefficiency
Designers often face significant challenges due to misalignment with other stakeholders and inefficiencies within the design process. Without a clear, structured approach, designers can struggle with conflicting priorities, vague objectives, and poor communication, all of which can impede their creativity and productivity. This misalignment can lead to repeated revisions, extended timelines, and designs that fail to meet user needs or business goals. Additionally, the lack of a well-defined process can stifle innovation and make it difficult for designers to translate their ideas into impactful solutions.
SOLUTION
Structured and Collaborative Approach
Designers can do their best work by embracing a structured and collaborative design process. By clearly defining each phase—starting with comprehensive user research and ideation, moving through iterative sketching and prototyping, and culminating in detailed design specifications—designers can ensure their work is both user-centered and strategically aligned. Focusing on user research helps designers gather critical insights, creating personas and user stories that inform every design decision. Regular collaboration and communication with business, product, engineering, and data science teams enable designers to align their vision with broader objectives, ensuring all voices are heard and respected. By adopting this structured methodology, designers can foster innovation, drive efficiency, and ultimately produce high-quality, impactful designs that resonate with users and achieve business goals.
"I miss your Design Philosophy.
It seems like designers are firstly focused on the ancillary design steps like accessibility and responsive design before they have figured out what design problem they are trying to solve."
Nathan - Lowe's Sr. Designer
PRODUCT DEFINITION
GATHER REQUIREMENTS
Business Explains Requirements
Conduct meetings with stakeholders to understand the business objectives, project requirements, and success criteria. Ask questions to clarify any ambiguities.
SET GOALS
Business Explains Goals
Define clear, measurable goals that align with the business objectives. These goals should address the problem the project aims to solve and the impact it should have.
CONTEXTUAL OVERVIEW
Product Shares Context and Plans
The product team provides a comprehensive overview of the project, including market analysis, user personas, and existing product features. This helps in understanding the broader context.
TIMELINE PLANNING
Product Shares Context and Plans
Collaborate with the product team to develop a realistic timeline. Identify key milestones and deadlines, and account for any dependencies or potential bottlenecks.
RESOURCE ALLOCATION
Product Shares Context and Plans
Determine the resources needed, such as team members, tools, and budget. The product team helps in allocating these resources effectively.
PRE-DESIGN ACTIVITIES
Design Communicates Needs and Manages Expectations
Identify what needs to be done before actual design work begins. This can include user research, competitive analysis, and setting up design tools.
USER RESEARCH​
Design Communicates Needs and Manages Expectations
Plan and conduct user research to gather insights about the target audience’s needs and behaviors.
COMPETITIVE ANALYSIS
Design Communicates Needs and Manages Expectations
Analyze competitors to understand industry standards and identify opportunities for differentiation.
DESIGN TOOLS AND SETUP
Design Communicates Needs and Manages Expectations
Ensure all design tools are set up and ready to use, and create necessary templates or guidelines.
EXPECTATION MANAGEMENT
Design Communicates Needs and Manages Expectations
Set clear expectations with stakeholders about the design process, timelines, and deliverables.
COMMUNICATION PLAN
Design Communicates Needs and Manages Expectations
Establish a communication plan to keep stakeholders informed about progress, changes, and feedback loops.
MILESTONES AND DELIVERABLES
Design Communicates Needs and Manages Expectations
Define key milestones and deliverables for the design phase, such as wireframes, prototypes, and final designs.
PRODUCT DEFINITION
GATHER REQUIREMENTS
Business Explains Requirements
Conduct meetings with stakeholders to understand the business objectives, project requirements, and success criteria. Ask questions to clarify any ambiguities.
SET GOALS
Business Explains Goals
Define clear, measurable goals that align with the business objectives. These goals should address the problem the project aims to solve and the impact it should have.
CONTEXTUAL OVERVIEW
Product Shares Context and Plans
The product team provides a comprehensive overview of the project, including market analysis, user personas, and existing product features. This helps in understanding the broader context.
TIMELINE PLANNING
Product Shares Context and Plans
Collaborate with the product team to develop a realistic timeline. Identify key milestones and deadlines, and account for any dependencies or potential bottlenecks.
RESOURCE ALLOCATION
Product Shares Context and Plans
Determine the resources needed, such as team members, tools, and budget. The product team helps in allocating these resources effectively.
PRE-DESIGN ACTIVITIES
Design Communicates Needs and Manages Expectations
Identify what needs to be done before actual design work begins. This can include user research, competitive analysis, and setting up design tools.
USER RESEARCH​
Design Communicates Needs and Manages Expectations
Plan and conduct user research to gather insights about the target audience’s needs and behaviors.
COMPETITIVE ANALYSIS
Design Communicates Needs and Manages Expectations
Analyze competitors to understand industry standards and identify opportunities for differentiation.
DESIGN TOOLS AND SETUP
Design Communicates Needs and Manages Expectations
Ensure all design tools are set up and ready to use, and create necessary templates or guidelines.
EXPECTATION MANAGEMENT
Design Communicates Needs and Manages Expectations
Set clear expectations with stakeholders about the design process, timelines, and deliverables.
COMMUNICATION PLAN
Design Communicates Needs and Manages Expectations
Establish a communication plan to keep stakeholders informed about progress, changes, and feedback loops.
MILESTONES AND DELIVERABLES
Design Communicates Needs and Manages Expectations
Define key milestones and deliverables for the design phase, such as wireframes, prototypes, and final designs.
PRODUCT BACKGROUND
In response to the evolving landscape of retail demands, Lowe's introduces CAPS, the Cluster and Assortment Planning Suite. Developed as an intuitive assortment planning tool, CAPS aims to streamline the assortment optimization process, facilitating efficient decision-making for Assortment Planners.
By integrating advanced data science methodologies, CAPS empowers planners to measure and analyze performance effectively, driving localization efforts and enhancing productivity through informed item/store stocking decisions.
The overarching objective of CAPS is to revolutionize the assortment planning workflow, fostering productivity enhancements and operational efficiencies by automating various steps of the Business Review (BR) and Product Line Review (PLR) processes.
​
At its core, assortment planning is pivotal in determining the optimal selection of items to be stocked at individual stores, tailored to customer preferences and available shelf space for product groups. By leveraging CAPS, Lowe's endeavors to delight customers by ensuring the availability of desired products while maximizing sales and margin potential.
The objectives of CAPS are twofold:
Firstly, to develop a cutting-edge assortment planning solution that prioritizes user-friendliness, accelerates speed to market, drives localization efforts, and boosts assortment productivity.
Secondly, CAPS seeks to enhance business user productivity by automating processes and minimizing manual intervention in the PLR/BR workflow.
Through these strategic initiatives, CAPS embodies Lowe's commitment to innovation, efficiency, and customer-centricity in the ever-evolving retail landscape.
OLD CUSTOMER JOURNEY
The old user journey was laden with inefficiencies, and superfluous pages presenting users with a labyrinth of extraneous pages that obstructed their progression. Its convoluted structure lacked a coherent flow, making it challenging for users to navigate seamlessly through the system.
Consequently, the journey suffered from dismal adoption rates, primarily attributed to the significant hurdles users faced in navigating and utilizing the platform effectively. The daunting complexity of the user interface deterred engagement, underscoring the pressing necessity for a redesign aimed at simplifying usability and enhancing the overall user experience.
DISCOVER
This page served as an initial exploration space, aiding in the identification of promising product groups suitable for a Product Line Review (PLR).
SPACE LENS
Although partially developed, this page intended to display available space for each item. However, incomplete backend data rendered the page non-functional for users.
PROJECTS
Acting as a data input hub, users utilized this page to input project-related information, facilitating streamlined project management.
ITEM PLANNING
Dedicated to providing comprehensive item information, this page served as a reference point for users engaging in item-related planning activities.
LEFT / RIGHT
Despite confusing terminology, the purpose of this page was to showcase historical data (Left) and potential outcomes post-assortment (Right), aiding users in informed decision-making.
CLUSTER
Users expressed skepticism regarding the trustworthiness of the system-generated store groupings on this page, hindering their adoption of the tool.
ASSORT
Characterized by overwhelming information and non-functional sliders, this page resembled a cluttered workspace, impeding user comprehension and functionality.
OUTCAP
Designated as the project closure point, this page facilitated the finalization of project-related activities and tasks.
INTAKE REQUESTS
Designed for user feedback submission in case of system issues, this page remained non-operational, limiting user interaction and input.
MERCHANDISE PLANNING
Providing a platform for merchandising plan comparisons, this page facilitated strategic decision-making processes related to merchandise planning initiatives.
NEW CUSTOMER JOURNEY
Assortment Planners pointed out that the Customer Journey isn't simply a straight path; it's more like a circle that keeps repeating. Steps 2, 3, and 4 follow each other, but then they cycle back again. Over the span of the 32 weeks they are working on their project, Assortment Planners continuously collaborate with their partners to determine which items to stock in the store. They start by gathering information, move on to making decisions, and then refining those decisions based on feedback. This process repeats throughout the project timeline, reflecting the ongoing nature of their work. Therefore, the tools utilized by Assortment Planners need to support this cyclical approach, enabling seamless iteration and adaptation as they navigate the journey.
CREATE PROJECT
Establish the foundational framework for your project, delineating key structures and requisite datasets for seamless execution.
WORKBOOK
Strategically select product groups for analysis and meticulously curate item listings to populate the workbook, laying the groundwork for subsequent decision-making processes.
CLUSTER
Employ advanced artificial intelligence algorithms to determine optimal store groupings, leveraging data-driven insights to enhance operational efficiency and strategic alignment.
ASSORT
Harness the power of AI-driven algorithms to discern the most appropriate items for stocking across designated stores, ensuring a tailored approach that maximizes customer satisfaction and sales potential.
PUBLISH
Conduct a comprehensive review of the entire project, scrutinizing item selections and strategic decisions to confirm alignment with organizational objectives and market demands before finalizing stocking decisions for store deployment.
COLLABORATION
Forging Success Through Collaboration
A Multidisciplinary Journey in Product Development
Building a Multifaceted Team
As the project unfolded, it quickly became apparent that the collaborative efforts of a diverse array of stakeholders were indispensable in navigating the inherent challenges of designing and building a product primarily by data scientists. With a multifaceted team comprising Business Partners, Subject Matter Experts, Product Management, Analytics, UX Design, Engineering Management, Front End Engineering, Back End Engineering, Data Science, Data Engineering, and Scrum specialists, each member brought a distinct set of skills and perspectives to the table. However, the initial stages of the project revealed significant gaps in understanding and functionality, underscoring the need for cohesive teamwork and shared learning.
​
Strategic Guidance and Domain Expertise
From the outset, Business Partners provided crucial context and requirements, offering insights into market demands and user expectations. This foundational understanding laid the groundwork for subsequent development efforts, ensuring alignment with overarching business objectives. Meanwhile, Subject Matter Experts lent their expertise in specific domains, enriching discussions with nuanced insights and practical considerations. Their input was instrumental in guiding decision-making processes, particularly in navigating complex industry landscapes and regulatory requirements.
​
Orchestrating the Project
Product Management played a pivotal role in orchestrating the project's trajectory, serving as a conduit between stakeholders and development teams. With a keen focus on market trends, customer needs, and product vision, Product Managers steered the project towards successful outcomes, balancing competing priorities and strategic considerations. Alongside them, Analytics specialists delved into the intricacies of data analysis, uncovering actionable insights and informing data-driven decision-making processes. Their contributions were instrumental in refining product features and optimizing performance based on empirical evidence.
​
Crafting User-Centric Experiences
In parallel, UX Design played a central role in shaping the user experience, translating stakeholder requirements and technical constraints into intuitive interfaces and seamless interactions. Through iterative design iterations and user testing, UX Designers ensured that the product resonated with end-users, fostering engagement and satisfaction. Meanwhile, Engineering teams grappled with the technical complexities of implementation, with Front End and Back End Engineers collaborating closely to translate design concepts into functional code. Their meticulous attention to detail and commitment to quality were essential in delivering a robust and scalable product architecture.
​
Harnessing Data and Agile Methodologies
Data Science and Data Engineering teams tackled the unique challenges posed by the project's data-centric nature, leveraging advanced algorithms and infrastructure to extract actionable insights from complex datasets. Their expertise in machine learning, predictive modeling, and data integration empowered the team to harness the full potential of available data assets, driving informed decision-making and performance optimization. Concurrently, Scrum methodologies provided a framework for agile project management, enabling iterative development cycles and fostering adaptability in response to evolving requirements and feedback.
​
Learning and Collaboration
As the project progressed, each iteration of the five distinct pages provided invaluable opportunities for team learning and collaboration. Challenges encountered along the way served as catalysts for innovation and growth, fostering a culture of continuous improvement and shared accountability. Through open communication channels and cross-functional collaboration, the team overcame obstacles, capitalized on opportunities, and ultimately delivered a product that surpassed initial expectations. This collaborative journey not only yielded a functional and impactful solution but also cultivated a sense of camaraderie and shared purpose among team members, laying the foundation for future successes.
NAVIGATING TO SUCCESS
Simplifying User Interactions Through Strategic Navigation Integration
STRATEGIC NAVIGATION INTEGRATION
In the development of this product, navigation emerged as a pivotal aspect intertwined with the procedural steps of the user journey. Recognizing the critical role of navigation in simplifying user interactions, the team strategically integrated navigational elements within each step of the process. From initial discovery to final project closure, seamless navigation pathways were meticulously designed to guide users through the product's functionalities with ease and clarity.
OVERCOMING STAKEHOLDER RESISTANCE
However, achieving alignment on the importance of navigation posed a significant challenge. Convincing both product and business stakeholders of the necessity to prioritize navigation as a means to enhance user experience required time and effort. Despite initial resistance, the team persisted in advocating for navigational improvements, emphasizing the direct impact on user satisfaction and adoption rates. Through collaborative dialogue and persuasive demonstrations, stakeholders gradually recognized the value proposition of streamlined navigation in simplifying users' lives and driving overall product success.
EMPOWERING USERS THROUGH INTUITIVE NAVIGATION
Ultimately, the integration of strategic navigation proved instrumental in empowering users to navigate the product effortlessly and accomplish their objectives efficiently. By aligning navigational elements with the user journey's procedural steps, the team succeeded in creating a cohesive and intuitive user experience. As users seamlessly navigated through the product's functionalities, the benefits of simplified navigation became evident, reinforcing stakeholders' confidence in the strategic approach. Through perseverance and collaborative advocacy, the team overcame initial resistance, ensuring that navigation remained a central pillar in facilitating user interaction and satisfaction.
PAGE STRUCTURE TEMPLATE
6 Essential Sections Deconstructed
1. PROJECT SUMMARY
The project summary served as the cornerstone of each page structure, providing a comprehensive overview of the project's objectives, scope, and current status. Serving as the starting point for user engagement, this section offered vital context and direction, guiding users through subsequent steps with clarity and purpose. By encapsulating key project details in a succinct summary, users were equipped with the necessary information to navigate the following sections with confidence and efficiency.
2. CREATE NEW OR LOAD EXISTING
Following the project summary, the option to create a new project or load an existing one laid the groundwork for user interaction, offering flexibility and continuity in project management. This pivotal decision point informed subsequent actions, determining whether users would embark on a fresh endeavor or continue with existing project data. By incorporating this choice into the page structure, the interface accommodated diverse user needs and workflows, ensuring a seamless transition into parameter selection and data manipulation.
3. MAKE PARAMETER SELECTIONS
Parametric selections constituted a pivotal stage in the user journey, enabling users to customize and tailor project parameters according to specific requirements and preferences. This section provided a comprehensive array of options and settings, empowering users to fine-tune project parameters with precision and efficiency. By centralizing parameter selection within the page structure, users could navigate this critical stage with ease, facilitating informed decision-making and strategic planning.
4. SHOW TABLE VALUES + MAKE CHANGES AS NECESSARY
The display of table values and the option to make changes formed a dynamic and interactive stage within the page structure, facilitating data visualization and manipulation. This section allowed users to interact with tabular data, reviewing existing values and making adjustments as needed. By integrating this functionality seamlessly into the interface, users could iterate on project parameters with agility, fostering a responsive and iterative approach to project management and analysis.
5. REVIEW FINAL CHANGES FOR APPROVAL
As users progressed through the page structure, the review of final changes for approval served as a pivotal checkpoint, ensuring accuracy and completeness before finalizing project adjustments. This section provided users with an opportunity to review and validate modifications, confirming alignment with project objectives and stakeholder requirements. By incorporating this review stage into the page structure, the interface promoted accountability and quality assurance, mitigating the risk of errors and oversights.
6. VIEW GRAPHICAL SUMMARY OF TABLE DATA
Concluding the user journey, the graphical summary of table data offered a visual representation of project insights and outcomes, enriching user understanding and facilitating strategic decision-making. This section transformed tabular data into intuitive visualizations, enabling users to glean actionable insights at a glance. By integrating graphical summaries into the page structure, the interface enhanced user comprehension and engagement, empowering users to derive maximum value from project data.
In summary, the six essential sections formed the foundational framework of each page structure, guiding users through a comprehensive and intuitive user journey. From project initiation to data visualization, each section played a distinct yet interconnected role in facilitating user interaction and achieving project objectives with efficiency and efficacy.
ENHANCING USER EXPERIENCE
Introducing New Elements for Tool Utilization
SELECTORS
Central to the functionality of this project were the newly created selectors, designed to facilitate user interaction and customization. These intuitive elements allowed users to choose from a range of options, parameters, and settings, tailoring their experience to meet specific requirements and preferences. By incorporating selectors into the tool's interface, users gained greater control and flexibility in manipulating project variables, empowering them to optimize outcomes and streamline workflows with ease and precision.
BUTTONS
In addition to selectors, the integration of buttons served as a vital component in enhancing user engagement and workflow efficiency. These interactive elements provided users with clear and actionable prompts, enabling them to initiate processes, confirm actions, and navigate between different stages of the tool. By strategically placing buttons within the interface, users were guided through the tool's functionalities with clarity and confidence, fostering a seamless and intuitive user experience that encouraged active participation and decision-making.
GRAPHICALLY VISUAL ELEMENTS
Furthermore, the inclusion of graphically visual elements played a crucial role in enhancing user comprehension and insight generation. These dynamic components transformed complex data sets and project insights into visually appealing representations, such as charts, graphs, and diagrams. By presenting information in a visually engaging format, users were able to quickly interpret trends, patterns, and relationships within the data, facilitating informed decision-making and strategic analysis. Through the incorporation of graphically visual elements, the tool not only provided users with valuable insights but also elevated the overall user experience, making data exploration and interpretation a more intuitive and engaging process.
ADOPTION
LEVERAGING ANALYTICS
For Informed Decision-Making
Analytical Insights
Analytics played a pivotal role in driving informed decision-making throughout the project lifecycle. By harnessing advanced data analysis techniques and algorithms, the team gained valuable insights into user behavior, system performance, and project outcomes. These analytical insights provided a deeper understanding of user interactions within the tool, allowing for the identification of usage patterns, pain points, and areas for improvement. Moreover, analytics facilitated proactive decision-making by highlighting trends and anomalies, empowering stakeholders to anticipate challenges and capitalize on opportunities in real-time.
Data-Driven Optimization
Furthermore, analytics served as a catalyst for continuous improvement and optimization efforts. By analyzing data collected from user interactions, the team was able to iteratively refine the tool's functionality, user interface, and overall user experience. Through A/B testing, cohort analysis, and other analytical methodologies, the team identified opportunities to enhance usability, increase user engagement, and drive user adoption. Additionally, analytics guided strategic decision-making by providing actionable insights into market trends, competitor performance, and customer preferences. By leveraging analytics, the team was able to iterate rapidly, respond to evolving user needs, and deliver a product that exceeded expectations.
FACTS & FIGURES
$629M
annual incremental sales
$100M
reduction in unproductive inventory in 2023
80%
adoption across business reviews
20%
reduction in stocking errors by the end of 2023
COLLABORATIVE EXCELLENCE
The Power of Teamwork Drove Project Success
Unified Efforts
The successful development and implementation of this project were made possible through the collective efforts of the entire team. With diverse skill sets, perspectives, and expertise, each team member played a crucial role in contributing to the project's success. Collaboration and cooperation were key principles that guided our interactions, allowing us to pool our talents and resources to overcome challenges and achieve common goals. Through open communication, mutual support, and a shared commitment to excellence, we were able to navigate complexities and drive the project forward with confidence and resilience.
Synergistic Dynamics
Working closely together, the team developed a deep understanding of each other's strengths, weaknesses, and working styles. This familiarity fostered a sense of cohesion and camaraderie, enabling us to anticipate each other's actions and coordinate our efforts seamlessly. As a result, we were able to operate with a high degree of efficiency and effectiveness, maximizing our collective impact and productivity. By leveraging our synergistic dynamics, we were able to tackle tasks with agility, adaptability, and innovation, ensuring that every aspect of the project was executed with precision and excellence.
The single most helpful part of this product refresh: that it was much simplified from the past tool saving us time working through our projects.
Ellie, Senior Assortment Planner
CONCLUSION
Uniting Efforts: A Synthesis of Collaborative Innovation
Fostering Transformation
Throughout the journey of this project, the collective efforts of a dedicated and diverse team have culminated in the creation of a transformative tool that revolutionizes user experience and decision-making processes. By harnessing the power of collaboration, innovation, and analytics, we have successfully navigated through challenges, leveraged opportunities, and delivered a solution that exceeds expectations. From the inception of the project to its implementation and beyond, each team member has played a vital role in shaping its evolution, contributing unique perspectives, skills, and insights along the way.
Empowering Success
As we reflect on the journey, it becomes evident that our collective achievements are greater than the sum of our individual contributions. Through collaboration, we have cultivated a culture of excellence, where teamwork, adaptability, and continuous improvement are celebrated and embraced. By harnessing the collective talents and expertise of our team, we have overcome obstacles, seized opportunities, and achieved remarkable outcomes. As we move forward, we carry with us the lessons learned, the bonds forged, and the successes achieved, knowing that together, we are capable of overcoming any challenge and realizing our shared vision of innovation and excellence.
